German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has sparked widespread domestic criticism following his unexpected announcement that approximately 80 percent of Syrians currently living in Germany should return to their home country within the next three years. The ambitious plan, which would affect nearly 800,000 people, has drawn immediate skepticism from political allies, opposition figures, and healthcare experts alike.
The contentious statement was made almost casually during a joint press conference in Berlin on Monday, following Merz's first meeting with Syria's interim President, Ahmed al-Scharaa. Responding to a journalist's question regarding repatriation plans, Merz stated: "In the longer perspective of the next three years—this was the wish of President al-Scharaa—around 80 percent of the Syrians currently residing in Germany should return to their home country."
This target would mean the repatriation of the vast majority of the roughly 950,000 Syrian nationals currently in Germany. Many of these individuals fled the civil war that ravaged Syria for 15 years before the fall of Bashar al-Assad's regime in late 2024. The current interim leader, al-Scharaa, who previously commanded militant Islamist groups, has expressed a strong desire for his compatriots to return and help rebuild the nation.
The sheer volume and tight timeframe of the proposed return have alarmed politicians across the spectrum. Anke Rehlinger (SPD), Minister-President of Saarland, criticized the Chancellor's approach, stating it was "not a smart idea" to present concrete figures and timelines that raise unfulfillable expectations. Even within Merz's conservative CDU, foreign policy expert Roderich Kiesewetter warned that the signal sent by these numbers is highly problematic, particularly regarding the potential loss of crucial healthcare workers. "If they return, we have a challenge," Kiesewetter noted.
The German Hospital Association (DKG) echoed these urgent concerns. DKG Vice President Henriette Neumeyer emphasized the critical role of Syrian medical professionals, who constitute the largest group of foreign doctors in Germany. With 5,745 Syrian doctors employed in German hospitals as of late 2024, Neumeyer warned that they hold "significant importance for healthcare provision."
Merz himself acknowledged this caveat during the press conference, clarifying that well-integrated professionals—specifically doctors and nurses—are welcome to stay. "We have an interest in ensuring that those who live with us, want to stay here, and are well integrated... absolutely remain in Germany," Merz said, while stressing that Syria also desperately needs its citizens back home.
Despite the German government's assessment that the Syrian civil war is effectively over following Assad's ouster, the realities of repatriation remain complex. Most Syrian refugees in Germany hold subsidiary protection status, which is valid only as long as they face harm from war or disaster in their home country. However, since 2016, approximately 250,000 Syrians have already acquired German citizenship, deeply embedding themselves into German society.
Opposition figures have vehemently condemned the Chancellor's remarks. Green Party MP Luise Amtsberg called the announcement "not only unrealistic but cynical," arguing that it ignores both the fragile security situation in Syria and the fact that many refugees are now an integral part of German society. Migration lawyer Osman similarly dismissed the sweeping repatriation proposal as a "scenario without foundation."
We use cookies to improve your experience. Privacy Policy